Earlier today I finished reading Mockingjay, the last book in The Hunger Games series. One thing that caught my attention before I even went to see the movie (which was before I read the series), was how people at work kept comparing The Hunger Games to Twilight. Mind you, aside from both being young adult fiction, these books are in two entirely different genres. Twilight is paranormal romance. The Hunger Games is Sci Fiction/Fantasy.
On any note, I thought I would take the time to write a post about how Twilight and The Hunger Games are not anywhere near the same. Be forewarned that there will be spoilers in this post as I have read both series in their entirety. So, if you haven’t read the books and are eagerly awaiting the movies to finish rolling out then I advise you to stop reading this and find something else to do with your time.
The Heroines
Katniss Everdeen – Katniss grows up in poverty and quickly learns how to survive through hunting and bartering. She’s incredibly selfless, caring more about those around her than herself which is what leads to her ending up in The Hunger Games. In The Hunger Games (book 1) Katniss seems to function like a puppet, doing whatever is necessary to stay alive. During Catching Fire (book 2) we get to see the beginnings of psychological break down in the heroin. However, she stays strong for the most part. Again, she selflessly casts her life aside for someone else, Peeta Mellark, a boy that happens to be in love with her. By book 3 (Mockingjay), Katniss is a total mental wreck. While one of my co-workers complained that having a weak heroin made her unrelatable, I thought that the natural progression of Katniss’s unstable psychological state given her circumstances was rather brilliant. Most other writers would have tried to preserve her sanity for the sake of making her a stronger heroine. But the fact that in the end she was almost completely broken down, gives Katniss a better sense of realism to me.
Bella Swan – Bella Swan gets whisked away from her hometown to start a new school year in Forks. At her new school she encounters Edward, the mysterious and handsome vampire that all the girls seem to want but none of them can get close to. Curiosity and attraction draws the two together and they eventually become a couple. Meanwhile, her best friend Jacob has also fallen in love with her, causing tension. Oh yeah, and if you didn’t already know, Jacob’s a werewolf, which adds more tension to the pot since werewolves and vampires HATE each other. Throughout the entirety of the series, Bella strings Jacob along while pining for Edward. Being the love interest of a vampire puts a target on her back and she ends up being pursued by various other vampires throughout the series. Bella is completely helpless though, so she counts on Edward and Jacob to save her time and time again. At the end of the series, once Edward has made her into a vampire, she finally repays her two love interests by saving them from being annihilated by the Volturi in a very anti-climatic ending to the series.
Do I even really need to compare the two? Katniss Everdeen is a survivor where as if Bella had ever been left alone in Twilight she would have been dead within a chapter. Katniss Everdeen would risk her life for her family and friends, whereas Bella’s only concern ever seemed to be Edward. Screw the rest of the people around her. Bella Swan is only relatable on the level that we all secretly want to have our cake and eat it too. Who wouldn’t want two gorgeous guys tirelessly pursuing them no matter how much you hurt them? But that is about the end of it. Beyond that, Bella is nothing more than a helpless whiny selfish girl.
On a different yet related note, I give both Kirsten Stewart and Jennifer Lawrence props for the way they acted in their roles as Bella and Katniss. I thought that both of these actresses were spot on with their interpretations of the characters.
The Love Triangle
In both of these movies, first come first serve does not apply. In The Hunger Games, Gale came before Peeta and yet Peeta got the girl. In Twilight, Jacob came before Edward and then Edward got the girl. Let’s face it, for the most part, in Twilight, everyone thought that Jacob should win in the end. Why? Because he was the one who was always there for Bella no matter what. The compassionate friend. The protector. The guy who would walk through hell and back to keep Bella safe and make her happy. And let’s face it, he was hotter . . . waaay hotter.
Some fans of The Hunger Games were upset that Katniss ends up with Peeta at the end of the series. They know that she has always wanted to end up with Gale. That’s clear from the very beginning of the series. But seriously, there’s no way that Gale could ever understand or sympathize with Katniss like Peeta can, considering that they both experienced The Hunger Games, not once but twice. I would imagine that it would be hard to be in a relationship with someone who didn’t understand that emotional agony that you faced on a day to day basis from having endured so much torture in your lifetime. Not only that, but Peeta’s complete selflessness made him a worthy love interest. And in the end, Katniss saw all of that and made the right decision. Sometimes love comes softly (yes, I took that from a movie).
Let’s get into other differences between the love triangles. Katniss was brought together with Peeta out of the necessity to survive. She played him from the beginning, despite that fact that his feelings towards her were always genuine. There were several moments when their lives hung in the balance that she began to feel more than the lies she was telling him. How could you not in that type of situation? When you don’t know if the next day will be your last, I would imagine that it makes you particularly vulnerable to such feelings. As soon as the games were over though, she made her true feelings clear. The only times that she baited Peeta back in were when it was necessary for the games or when she was looking for a way to save him. There was never a time that she led Peeta on without a deeper purpose behind it. When everything was said and done after the first Hunger Games, she let both Gale and Peeta know where she stood. There was never anything hidden behind her actions. And respectably, both men decided to stand back and let Katniss figure out her feelings for herself. There was no fighting or emotional tugging and pulling between the men to muddy up Katniss’s judgement.
This was completely the opposite during Twilight. While there were moments of peace between Edward and Jacob, a large amount of the series they were pitted against one another, with Jacob aggressively trying to win Bella’s affection. Unfortunately, Bella played into this, leading Jacob on and causing the vast amount of the drama that occurred between Jacob and Edward because of it.
The Overall Stories
I watched The Hunger Games movie before I read the book. To be honest, within a few minutes of the movie starting, I was in love. It was awesome, though much less violent than I was anticipating. So, I believe it was the next day or a few days later I went out and bought all of the books in the series. A co-worker of mine convinced me to start with the first book, even though I would have preferred to start with the second. I actually ended up reading the first and second book at the same time. One thing I liked was that the movie very closely followed the book. There were only a few things that I think I would have paid a bit more attention to had I read the book before seeing the movie. One thing I didn’t like about the books . . . and this goes for all three of them, is that it takes FOREVER to get into the action. Seriously, a good 80% of the books are all about character development and a slow build. And there are plenty of anti-climatic scenes that I thought really should have been focused on more. For example, Prim dying towards the end of Mockingjay. I felt no sadness whatsoever. In fact, I felt more sorry when Finnick died. He was my favorite character from Catching Fire and Mockingjay aside from Katniss. Peeta was my third favorite character, followed by Buttercup.
It wasn’t even so much the fact that Prim wasn’t at the top of my list of characters as it was that Suzanne Collins spent less than a page describing her death. In fact, it was more like a paragraph (please note that I’m too lazy to get up and actually go count the paragraphs).
Another thing that really bothered me was how Katniss set out for the Capitol on her own, with the encouragement of others, and it ended up being a fruitless effort because the rebels caught up with them anyways. She never actually got to Snow, which made a large portion of Mockingjay pretty much seem pointless. So many people died in the attempt to get to Snow . . . including Finnick (R.I.P.). It just really really bothered me.
I know that there was something else I wanted to mention but I just drew a blank so I’ll move on to Twilight.
I think if you look up anticlimatic in the dictionary, there will be a description for the ending of Twilight. Imagine over half a book building up to this epic battle that never happens. Yup, that about sums it up. In fact, the last book in the Twilight saga, Breaking Dawn, can be summed up in two words: sex and disappointment. I’m still confused as to why they decided to split it up into two movies. Which brings me to another point . . . Breaking Dawn was one of the worst movies I have ever seen. The wedding scene was so long that I literally felt like I was attending someone’s wedding that I didn’t give a crap about.
But anyways, I digress. I also did not start reading Twilight until I had already seen the first movie (which I hated). Don’t ask me why I decided to further punish myself by reading through the horribly written saga. In truth, I know that the answer is because it was the big thing at the time and I like to stay on top of things like that. But to be honest, between the bad writing and the selfish estrogen soaked storyline, I had a hard time making it through and am not particularly anticipating the last movie. I think a lot of people are sick of it at this point though.
Getting off subject again. So yeah, another funky thing about Twilight is the imprinting. There’s nothing like watching a teenage boy suddenly fall in love with a baby. While I know that’s not exactly how it works, the whole concept is bizarre and rather disturbing.
In conclusion, do I think that The Hunger Games is anything like Twilight. Not in the slightest. The fact that there are two guys after one girl is about where it stops. If you’ve read this entire article then I don’t even need to state which series I enjoyed more. Though, to be honest, neither of them really blew my mind. I guess I’ll just have to wait until the next Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings comes out (I don’t literally mean the next Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings, but rather something new and similar to them).